{title}

Login About AIU

About AIU

 
 
 

Topics

What you're thinking!

From: Hi Fructose

I may be oversimplifying here but I always liked Aristotle's thoughts on life-everything in moderation. Yes there is an obesity problem in this country.…

- Bethry

From: Is thin really in?

Positive reinforcement only goes so far with kids. Super thin models are not the only images that teens see everyday that make them think that anything…

- gypsycat

From: Is thin really in?

I understand that some of these said modesl aren't naturally thin but you cannot change that. You can only change what is in your life. If you don't…

- RoslynP

Controversy in Ads

Ads, Lies & Lawsuits

 
Ads, Lies & Lawsuits

Dr. Sabrina Segal

It was supposed to fight germs and viruses and stop a cold.

Americans have shelled out hundreds of millions since 1999 to keep the cold & flu at bay with an herbal medicine known as Airborne.

But the clinical trial backing the product’s efficacy was apparently a sham – or so say consumer advocates. Airborne is similar in composition to a vitamin supplement, but not the cure for the common cold. One alleged false advertising claim resulted in a class action lawsuit and ended in a $23 million dollar settlement. But even while consumers claim refunds, the product is still on the shelves in drugstores and supermarkets nationwide.

How can this be? Marketing consultant, Rob Frankel says “the stuff that generally kills a brand is endangerment, not ineffectiveness” and what may fly in the face of convention may be embraced “by all those people who dump on Western medicine.”

Airborne has repositioned itself as a supplement that “boosts the immune system with seven herbal extracts, and a proprietary blend of vitamins, electrolytes, amino acids, and antioxidants.” The revamped message is on target with today’s hot health trends, relying on buzz words common to the dietary supplement industry.

But all may not be well in the land of Airborne. Its foes still think that it’s being falsely advertised and inaccurately stoked in the cold remedy section of stores. Another lawsuit is pending and the litigation is “about stopping the company from bogus marketing of the product.”

“As a brand, Airborne has a lot of trust with consumers. Strong brands tend to survive and consumers are willing to forgive.”

Have you tried Airborne? Has it work for you? Would you consider trying it, knowing now what you do about the Airborne controversy?

Photograph Credit:
Sabrina Segal

 

94 Comments

11. darkrose91 |May. 26, 2008 @ 9:58 AM

 
non-member comment
I have used Airborne a couple of times and it did help to boost my immune system but I only use it when I cant get to my grandmothers to get some of her echinaceia. I have Graves Disease so I can tell a difference since I am always getting sick if I havent taken an immunity booster.
 

12. TaronBaker |May. 26, 2008 @ 6:56 PM

 
TaronBaker's avatar
Vitamins are good in some cases if used right. I give my kids vitamin C tablets everyday to keep all colds away and it has worked for many years for where we live. When winter comes I keep them fulled up with the Vitamin C tablets to fight any germs that are spreaded around. Vitamin C does wonders.
 

13. ambdru |May. 27, 2008 @ 2:37 PM

 
non-member comment
I think this is an age-old strategy. Like in the olden days when a traveling salesman would pitch his snake oil cures all. Many of the products marketed today have the claims of instant cures, loose 2 sizes in a week, and so on. Most people who use the products do believe in them, and think they do the job they claim. I think it is a lot of mind over matter, and some buyer beware.
 

14. Steve |May. 27, 2008 @ 6:55 PM

 
non-member comment
I have not tried Airborne nor would I at this point. I have however had friends and coworkers who have used the product with mixed results. I would not use it knowing what I know now simply because of cost. Why would I spend the extra money on this product when I could purchase a bottle of vitamin C for a third of the cost? Vitamin C and some effervescent to make your drink bubble is basically what this product has to offer. Of course large doses of vitamin C will aid in fighting off a cold we don’t need a teacher to tell us this.
The manufactures of Airborne should however be commended for their brilliant marketing staff. They have done a spectacular job of marketing the product both before and after their lawsuit. The advertisement “created by a teacher” is brilliant. This lends to the products credibility from a figure most people know and trust. They should also be commended for the use of the word effervescent in their product description. “Airborne Effervescent Health Formula” The product description would not sound as impressive if they used Airborne the Bubbly Health formula.
Great packaging , well thought out product descriptions , marketing to a large target group all with a disclaimer relieving the manufacture of any liability. This is a case of poor marketing ethics. The marketers in this case were more concerned with company profits than they were their customers.
 

15. jenn123 |May. 28, 2008 @ 12:26 PM

 
jenn123's avatar
I am a firm believer of Airborne. We keep it at my house religiously . I think it works!
 

16. JohnHudak |May. 28, 2008 @ 1:22 PM

 
non-member comment
I think that there are a lot of different herbal medicine that does help different types of ailments. However, a lost of cold/flu drugs have different compounds in them that actually help more than just vitamin C and minerals/anti-oxidants. Some also have expectorants(which help breathing)pain-killing drugs that sooth the throat temporarily and many other compounds. The think is is that you never can trust too many herbal supplements because most of them are not regulated by the food and drug administration,or FDA, unlike almost all cold/flu drugs that are sold in Walgreens and other stores. These drugs are made by reputable companies like Shering Plough and Proctor & Gamble. Companies that have a reputation for showing results and documentation of their workings. Not some herbal hippie drug that no one really know about, for all we know, the drug could just be snake oil like a lot of phony health supplement out there. I would not trust them unless there was evidence and that is what people should look for when shopping this sector. If they are lying about their product or if the product does not contain what it says it does on the label (like a lot of companies do) then I think yes...people should sue the pants off of them!!!
 

17. CPage |May. 28, 2008 @ 1:37 PM

 
non-member comment
I found this story very interesting. I suffer from colds at least two times per year without fail. I am always looking for a product that delivers its claim. I am still looking. I have never seen the packaging from Airborne that stated prevention and cure of the common cold. There is doubt in my mind that the product was marketed that way. A “settlement” does not always mean “guilty.” Presently, Airborne claims to boost ones immune system using their supplement. The product provides herbs and high doses of vitamins to do this. Scientific research does show that vitamins and some herbs do boost ones immune system. There are other products on the market that do claim shortening the duration of a cold and lessening the symptoms. I have tried several of these products with no success. Could those company’s be in violation of false advertising as well? Only time will tell.
 

18. wjwright |May. 28, 2008 @ 2:10 PM

 
non-member comment
I have tried the Airborne product before. It worked very well and I still take before and after a flight. Like any medication or vitamins, some work for you and some do not. I did not believe it would prevent a cold, but would boost your immune system. So, this is not news to me. I am sure the product took some hits. But, it still sales very well and many people who I have talked too, still believe in the product.
 

19. mistyshank |May. 29, 2008 @ 11:19 AM

 
non-member comment
Used and love the product. Think they were just misunderstood as to what remedy was supposed to do. I was never under the impression that it cured a cold only that it would help you fight one off by building up your immune system w/ vitamins.
 

20. pkaer |May. 29, 2008 @ 2:06 PM

 
non-member comment
I have never used Airborne and I will never use it. After reading this article I feel the question should not be can the company recover from the lawsuit but should the company be allowed to recover. The company knowingly misrepresented their product once. Will they do it again and should they be given the opportunity to try? I don't think they should.
 

 <  1 2 3 4 >  Last »

Sign-in & Let your voice be heard!







Forgot your password?
Sing-Up