{title}

Login About AIU

About AIU

 
 
 

Topics

What you're thinking!

From: Hi Fructose

I may be oversimplifying here but I always liked Aristotle's thoughts on life-everything in moderation. Yes there is an obesity problem in this country.…

- Bethry

From: Is thin really in?

Positive reinforcement only goes so far with kids. Super thin models are not the only images that teens see everyday that make them think that anything…

- gypsycat

From: Is thin really in?

I understand that some of these said modesl aren't naturally thin but you cannot change that. You can only change what is in your life. If you don't…

- RoslynP

Controversy in Ads

Ads, Lies & Lawsuits

 
Ads, Lies & Lawsuits

Dr. Sabrina Segal

It was supposed to fight germs and viruses and stop a cold.

Americans have shelled out hundreds of millions since 1999 to keep the cold & flu at bay with an herbal medicine known as Airborne.

But the clinical trial backing the product’s efficacy was apparently a sham – or so say consumer advocates. Airborne is similar in composition to a vitamin supplement, but not the cure for the common cold. One alleged false advertising claim resulted in a class action lawsuit and ended in a $23 million dollar settlement. But even while consumers claim refunds, the product is still on the shelves in drugstores and supermarkets nationwide.

How can this be? Marketing consultant, Rob Frankel says “the stuff that generally kills a brand is endangerment, not ineffectiveness” and what may fly in the face of convention may be embraced “by all those people who dump on Western medicine.”

Airborne has repositioned itself as a supplement that “boosts the immune system with seven herbal extracts, and a proprietary blend of vitamins, electrolytes, amino acids, and antioxidants.” The revamped message is on target with today’s hot health trends, relying on buzz words common to the dietary supplement industry.

But all may not be well in the land of Airborne. Its foes still think that it’s being falsely advertised and inaccurately stoked in the cold remedy section of stores. Another lawsuit is pending and the litigation is “about stopping the company from bogus marketing of the product.”

“As a brand, Airborne has a lot of trust with consumers. Strong brands tend to survive and consumers are willing to forgive.”

Have you tried Airborne? Has it work for you? Would you consider trying it, knowing now what you do about the Airborne controversy?

Photograph Credit:
Sabrina Segal

 

94 Comments

91. dzoretic |Jun. 12, 2008 @ 11:14 AM

 
non-member comment
I personally have never taken this product. I am on a lot of prescription drugs, and the lack of scientific medical testing could be dangerous. Without testing, I would not know if there are any active ingredients that would have an interaction with my prescriptions. This leads to my second reason for not using this product. There is no known cure for the common cold, and advertising that any product can cure or prevent a common cold, just isn’t so. Marketing: An Introduction by Armstrong and Kotler sights deceptive promotion as “misrepresenting the products features or performance”. Which is a charge that can and has been made of this company. I also disagree with the concept of marketing vitamins as cold preventers. This inflates the price of the product. Purchasing the same ingredients at the vitamin counter at the local drugstore, would be much cheaper.
 

92. rollin |Jul. 13, 2008 @ 11:31 AM

 
rollin's avatar
It may be hard to think that each and everyone of us has what it takes to fight off the cold and flu. heck we even have the capability of fighting off the germs that plague our world. but through the inovation of medicine and the evloution of marketing mixed with the scare tactics that are used to herd the sheep we call people in this world we have forgotten about it. We are given the immune system for a reason. I know that yes you have to get a sniffle nose now and then to help the system to learn but if you steralize everything around you then it is not going to work. I think that the scare tactics and the ads that are put on television for medication should be banned! Let your bidy do the work. Listen to your body and it will tell you what you need to know. I also know that this is going to be looked at with critical eyes. I also know that there are people out there who need medication. but as for the everyday germs dont you think that we are going a bit far with this.
 

93. Tangor |Aug. 23, 2008 @ 8:13 PM

 
non-member comment
Okay, so there's a lot of discussion on this matter.
I and my family have used Airborne. It's not a cure-all, though at one point it may have been, I never saw that packaging. It does work as an immune booster, though. My wife and I have researched herbs, vitamins and minerals for years and we know what the ingredients in Airborne are capable of. We have, indeed, used the same ingredients for years, but it is rather convenient to get them all in one package.
I am much more worried about pharmaceuticals than I am about natural products. Why, you may ask. Because I know these companies and their mentality. I also know the ingredients in many of their products and I wouldn't feed these chemicals to rats, much less give them to humans and tell them it will cure anything! As for being FDA Approved! Who do you think funds the FDA! What about the staff members! Check it out some time. The FDA is funded and staffed by the pharmaceutical companies and they sure aren't going to regulate the very companies that put them in their cushy offices. If they did, they'd loose revenue and their jobs.
What I know about this subject is scary. Do your research and you'll find what I have and shy away from pharmaceuticals at every chance.
 

94. hagutie01 |Sep. 27, 2008 @ 11:35 PM

 
non-member comment
I don't know what they talking about, airborne works for me. I work at a company where there is a lot people working closely together an when cold season comes everyone shares their airborne.

I also worked as a teachers aid at one point and one of the main issues was catching something for one of the kids which happened frequently. A teacher is subject to a lot of germs in the environment in which they work. The teacher is the personality symbol used to help consumers remember the product.
 

« First  <  8 9 10

Sign-in & Let your voice be heard!







Forgot your password?
Sing-Up